Mentalisms

Focus

Creation of inner representations of external realities

Principal Metaphors

  • Knowledge is … external, objectified truths/reality
  • Knowing is … internal representations
  • Learner is … an internal observer
  • Learning is … internalizing
  • Teaching is … representing

Originated

Ancient (entrenched in the language)

Synopsis

Mentalisms reach across any theory that (1) assumes a separation of mental from physical (inner from outer, subjective from objective, etc.) and (2) casts learning in terms of mental images, models, encodings, or other inner representations of the existing world. Some sort of barrier – typically the body, or fallible senses, or faulty subjective interpretations – is seen to prevent direct, first-hand knowledge of reality. The measure of truth among Mentalisms tends to be the extent to which internal representations match with external reality.

Commentary

Among the many criticisms of Mentalism, the most frequently cited, and perhaps the most condemning, the perspective’s need for a “homunculus” – an inner being who observes mind-based representations of reality. The assumption that there is another level of being who is inside, watching, presents a question of how that homunculus is making sense of its reality – that is, does one’s homunculus have its own inner homunculus, and so on? More broadly, the term “Mentalisms” actually comes out of Behaviorisms, where it was employed to distinguish their asserted-to-be-scientific study of observable behaviors from assumed-to-be-unscientific discussions of mind-based cognition. As with many dualisms, the mentalism–behaviorism binary was popularly seen to span the full spectrum of possibility, and thus blinded many to such untenable separations as thought from action, self from other, individual from collection, and human from more-than-human.

Map Location



Please cite this article as:
Davis, B., & Francis, K. (2020). “Mentalisms” in Discourses on Learning in Education. https://learningdiscourses.com.


⇦ Back to Map
⇦ Back to List